TSCM Company: how to choose one
Choosing a TSCM company (technical surveillance countermeasures) is difficult because you cannot easily judge the work: if a sweep finds nothing, a thorough inspection and a superficial one look the same from outside. This page sets out the questions worth asking any provider, and how Risk3, an independent TSCM company led by a founder practising in Hong Kong since 1992, answers them. We deliver TSCM as a Privacy Audit: an audit of whether anyone can hear or see what happens in the spaces that matter to you.
Seven questions to ask a TSCM company
Do you sell surveillance or security products?
A provider who sells detectors, secure phones or security systems has a reason to find a problem their product solves. Risk3 sells no surveillance or security products, takes no commission or referral fees, and buys its test equipment outright.
What will you examine besides the radio spectrum?
A walk round with a detector is not a sweep. Expect a radio-frequency examination, a physical search of the fabric of the room, inspection of telephony, conference and audio-visual systems, and thermal imaging, non-linear junction detection and optical lens detection where the environment calls for them.
Which threats can your equipment detect?
Ask specifically about devices that use the mobile network, Wi-Fi in the 2.4 GHz, 5 GHz and 6 GHz bands, Bluetooth and Bluetooth Low Energy, devices that transmit in bursts or hop frequencies, and devices that do not transmit at all: recorders disguised as USB drives, calculators, air purifiers, shredders and other office items, and hidden cameras. Risk3 keeps its equipment and training current as new threats appear.
How long will you spend in each room?
A single boardroom done properly typically takes two to six hours, depending on its size and the equipment in the room. A quote for a whole floor in an hour is a warning sign.
How do you price, and what is fixed?
Be wary of open-ended hourly pricing with no defined scope. Risk3 quotes a fixed fee in advance from a red-yellow-green floor plan: red for rooms where a leak would be unrecoverable, priced first; yellow for rooms next to them or within earshot; green for the rest, as time allows; travel at cost.
What will I receive, and can my lawyers rely on it?
You should receive a written report, delivered only to you, or to your lawyers at your instruction, and any find should be photographed, documented and preserved with a continuity record that your lawyers can rely on; whether evidence is admitted is for the court. Risk3 works alongside counsel and has given expert witness reporting and oral evidence to the courts of Hong Kong and Singapore.
Who will actually do the work, and how discreetly?
Ask who will be on site and what their experience is. Risk3 is led by its founder and principal consultant, Alan Jeffries, who has practised counter-surveillance in Hong Kong since 1992 and in Japan and Singapore since 1993. Most sweeps are delivered out of hours, with discreet paperwork that still describes the service accurately and any building-management explanation agreed in advance.
What Risk3 does
- Privacy Audits (corporate bug sweeps) of boardrooms, executive offices and residences, with executive vehicles included only as part of a wider corporate audit;
- hidden camera detection, including hotels;
- boardroom and meeting sweeps and in-conference monitoring;
- TSCM programmes of scheduled re-sweeps;
- pre-move-in sweeps and secure fit-out advice;
- Cyber TSCM, the network as a listening surface;
- digital investigations, including mobile device forensics.
Where we work
Risk3 is headquartered in Hong Kong and works in Hong Kong, Macau, Singapore, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand, Malaysia and the Philippines, and on occasion in Australia and New Zealand. See also TSCM Singapore.
What you say in private is your business; keeping it that way is ours.
Choosing a TSCM company: common questions
What does a TSCM company do?
A TSCM company finds and defeats technical surveillance: listening devices, hidden cameras, trackers and compromised phone, conference and network systems. The core service, which Risk3 calls a Privacy Audit, is a sweep of the rooms, homes and venues where sensitive conversations happen, followed by a written report and practical advice.
How do I choose a TSCM company?
Ask whether they sell products, what they examine besides the radio spectrum, which threats their equipment detects, how long they spend per room, how they price, what report you receive, and who will do the work. Independence, method and time on site matter more than a list of equipment.
Why does independence matter in TSCM?
A provider that sells security products has a commercial reason to find problems those products solve. An independent provider such as Risk3, which sells no products and takes no commissions, has no reason to recommend anything you do not need.
What are corporate TSCM services?
Corporate TSCM services cover boardrooms, executive offices, residences, hotel suites and event venues, usually delivered out of hours and scoped by risk. Risk3 delivers them as a Privacy Audit; executive vehicles can be included as part of a wider corporate audit. They often include scheduled programmes and pre-move-in sweeps.
How much do TSCM services cost?
It depends on the rooms, not the building. Risk3 quotes a fixed fee in advance from a red-yellow-green floor plan, with the highest-risk rooms priced first and travel at cost. The first confidential consultation carries no fee.
Are TSCM companies regulated?
Requirements vary by country. Few places have a licence specific to TSCM, but security, investigation and radio laws can still apply to parts of an engagement, so ask any provider how it works lawfully where your premises are, and check its method, independence and reporting for yourself.
Is Risk3 a TSCM company in Singapore as well as Hong Kong?
Risk3 is based in Hong Kong and has worked in Singapore since 1993. See TSCM Singapore.
What is a TSCM security consultant?
A TSCM security consultant carries out sweeps and advises on reducing eavesdropping risk: room design, access control, meeting practice and programmes of re-sweeps. At Risk3 the same people who sweep also advise, so recommendations come from what was found.
These answers are general guidance, not advice on any specific situation. If your concern involves your personal safety rather than commercial confidentiality, put your safety first and contact the Police.
Speak to us before you speak in that room
The first confidential consultation carries no fee, and if a sweep is not the right answer we will say so. Call from a personal device, away from the suspected area.
